Thursday, December 15, 2011

Japan Gone Nuts: NISA Declares No Contaminated Water Leak From Fuku-I, in the Past, Now, and the Future

At this point, I can only laugh. Totally predictable.

As the national government under Prime Minister Noda (who looks like a popular manga character Patalliro, except Pata is extremely smart) prepares to declare a cold shutdown "state" and is about to become the laughing stock of the world, the Nuclear and Industrial Safety Agency is busy rewriting the definition of "leak".

Tokyo Shinbun reports that NISA has decided to basically "nullify" the leaks of contaminated water from Fukushima I Nuclear Power Plant in the past, and declare that there will be no leak in the future either, even if there is actually a leak or deliberate discharge. Why? Because NISA says so.

From Tokyo Shinbun (via Asyura, so that the link doesn't disappear; 12/16/2011):

保安院 海への汚染水 ゼロ扱い

NISA considers the amount of contaminated water into the ocean to be zero


There have been several leaks of water contaminated with radioactive materials from Fukushima I Nuclear Power Plant. Tokyo Shinbun has found out through own investigation that the Nuclear and Industrial Safety Agency under the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry has treated the amount of the leaks as "zero" from a legal [or regulatory] point of view, because it was a "state of emergency". The Agency has said it will treat the future leaks and deliberate discharges into the ocean the same way. The national government is scheduled to declare a "cold shutdown state" on December 16, but we are suspicious of the government's position that seems to ignore the suppression of the radioactive materials released from the plant, which is one of the important conditions [of the cold shutdown "state"].


The Nuclear Reactor Regulation Law specifies that the operator needs to set the maximum amount of radioactive materials released into the ocean for each nuclear power plant (total emission control). In the case of Fukushima I Nuke Plant, the maximum amount allowed is 220 billion becquerels per year for radioactive cesium. The amount is set to zero again at the beginning of a new fiscal year.


However, a leak of highly contaminated water was found on April 2 near the Reactor 2 water intake, and TEPCO conducted a discharge of low contamination water that was stored in a tank inside the plant buildings to make space to store the highly contaminated water.


This leak and the discharge alone released radioactive materials outside the plant to the tune of 4,700 terabecquerels (according to TEPCO's estimate), already more than 20,000 times as much as the maximum amount allowed.


Both domestic and foreign research institutions have disputed TEPCO's estimate as "too low".


On December 4, the water that contained 26 billion becquerels of radioactive strontium was found leaking into the ocean from the apparatus that evaporates and condenses the treated water.


Furthermore, the storage tanks that are set up inside the compound are expected to become full in the first half of the next year. The water in these storage tanks also contains radioactive strontium. TEPCO is contemplating the discharge of the water into the ocean after further decontaminating it, but facing the protest from the fisheries associations the company has said it will postpone the discharge for now.


Responding to the questions from Tokyo Shinbun, NISA emphasized that responding to the accident came first, and Fukushima I Nuke Plant was in a "state of emergency" where it was not possible to stop the leak, due to the damage the plant had sustained, and that was the reason for not applying the rule of "total emission control" and treating the 4,700-terabequerel leak as zero leak.


The special treatment under the "state of emergency" will last until the accident winds down, according to the Agency; but it was vague as to how long the special treatment will last, saying "it will be decided in the future discussions".


The Agency said even if the treated water that contains radioactive materials is released into the ocean, the Agency will continue to treat it as zero release.

Well, why should NISA stop at the water leak? They should simply declare that there was no emission of radioactive materials in the air, because the plant was in a state of emergency and in no shape to prevent the emission.

The national government declaring a cold shutdown "state" on broken reactors without even knowing where the corium has gone; government experts declaring 20 millisievert radiation is totally OK after one-month deliberation; the government agency declaring there was, is, will be no contaminated water leak or discharge from Fuku-I even if there was, is, will be a leak or discharge.

Gone nuts.


Anonymous said...

Carte blanche to pollute the Pacific, because it is an emergency? Wow. That's... something else.

Anonymous said...


This is clearly some form of delusional state - psychosis, even - to deny what is, declare it to be the opposite.

4,700T Bq = 0 Bq.

It is not really possible to get one's mind around how a mind that thinks like that operates.

How much would "total emission control", which Tepco clearly desires not to implement, cost?

What are the steps involved in "total emission control"?

Are other nuclear plants committed to "total emission control", as Fuku Daiichi clearly was at some point? (A requirement of the licensing process?)

Can all other nuke plants in Japan now safely abandon, at some future time once another "accident" occurs, any similar commitment previously undertaken to implement "total emission control", as part of their licenses, safety manuals?

Niigata said...

As you said in the previous post, it did not happen in Fukushima, all is good ...
There will be a big problem in Japan, or as you wake up and you hang all those people up there in short! (Gov, Daisen city's mayor and Nahara-machi and others like that too ...)
Either you will all die !!!!

arevamirpal::laprimavera said...

People in Japan are going hysterical over PM Noda's remark that the nuke accident is over. It's over. Hahahahaha. And there are people who rely on MSM TV and newspapers calling their net-based children and telling them "See, it's nothing to worry about!" hahahahaha.

Anonymous said...

Mission Accomplished. I'll be looking forward to the next "end" of the nuclear accident, in a few years. Or maybe decades. Or centuries. Or millenia. The way things are going, that's how long it's going to take for the radiation to go away.

Mauibrad said...

Pathological liars. When they get a supercritical explosion or hundreds of thousands if not millions of of their countrymen dying of cancer in a few years, they won't be able to deny and lie through it then.

Anonymous said...

Up yours, Noda!

Anonymous said...

Hate to say it..but at least British Petrol (BP) agreed OIL had leaked into the ocean. In Japan, per the government, because you can not see "radioactivity"--its not there. Anyone who says NO radioactive materials or ZERO release into the ocean needs to swim in the Fukushima a lovely glow to the skin....To say these people are NUTS is to insult anyone with mental illness.

Anonymous said...

Welcome to the politics of Magic Realism. These guys have nothing on G.G.Marquez.

Noda has volte-face on three important issues revealing him to be a shill of his puppet masters.
i. The promise to explore alternative energy and wean Japan off Nuclear. This was explicitly slain with his UN speech.
ii.TPP. Same only in Hawaii.
iii. Now this.

WTF is this guy on?

There is only one explanation and that is Japan is close to the end of its economic/financial tether. I maintain that if they dared tell the terrible truth, then Japan is truly fuckushima'd...and so the game continues to the end.

Very sad and depressing really. What a ship of fools.

Anonymous said...

Arrest the guy for fraud,corruption and accessory to genocide.

Anonymous said...

Noda serves his oyabun.

Post a Comment