Showing posts with label zero nuclear policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label zero nuclear policy. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 18, 2012

New Energy Policy of "Unremitting Examination and Revision", Says Noda Administration, Not "Zero Nuke" (Sorry, Angela)


So, the policy about zero nuclear plants operating in Japan by 2030 first became the policy about zero nuclear plants operating in Japan by some time in 2030s, and then the wording was completely dropped from the official cabinet decision document. Now, what is in the cabinet decision?

This is:

The Japanese government is committed to the "unremitting (ceaseless) examination and revision" of the new energy policy.

Reading the Jiji Tsushin article (9/19/2012; part), it almost reads as if this "unremitting examination and revision" is indeed the new energy policy itself:

原発ゼロ、明記せず=新エネ戦略「不断の見直し」-閣議決定文

Zero nuke is not explicitly written in the cabinet decision document, the new energy strategy "unremitting revision"

 政府は19日の閣議で、今後のエネルギー政策に関して「『革新的エネルギー・環境戦略』を踏まえ、不断の検証と見直しを行いながら遂行する」との方針を決定した。同戦略は2030年代の原発稼働ゼロを目指すとしているが、閣議決定の文言に「原発ゼロ」は盛り込まなかった。

The government [Noda administration] made the decision to "execute the future energy policy with unremitting examination and revision, based on the "revolutionary [innovative, if you so prefer] energy and environmental strategy"" during the cabinet meeting on September 19. The strategy is supposed to aim at zero nuclear power plant operating in 2030s, but "zero nuclear" was not mentioned in the official document of the cabinet decision.

 藤村修官房長官は同日午前の記者会見で「戦略を踏まえてエネルギー環境政策の具体化を図る」と述べた。枝野幸男経済産業相は閣議後会見で、「閣議決定の文書には入っていないが、(戦略は)閣議でオーソライズされた」と表明した。古川元久国家戦略担当相も「こういう閣議決定の形を取ったことの裏に意図はない」と述べた。

Chief Cabinet Secretary Osamu Fujimura said in the morning press conference, "We will plan for concrete actions for the energy and environmental policies based on the strategy." Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry Yukio Edano said in the press conference after the cabinet meeting, "(The strategy) is not mentioned in the document for the cabinet decision, but was authorized in the cabinet meeting." Minister in charge of national strategy Motohisa Furukawa said, "There is no hidden agenda behind the way we made our decision."

 2005年に策定された原子力政策大綱なども、本文自体は閣議決定の対象としていない。

The body text of the Nuclear Energy Policy Guideline compiled in 2005, for example, was not the subject of the cabinet decision either.

 政府の「エネルギー・環境会議」が14日策定した戦略をめぐっては、経済界などが強く反発。18日の国家戦略会議でも民間議員が反対意見を述べ、承認が見送られていた。

The business circle and others were strongly against the strategy that was agreed on by the "Energy and Environmental Conference" of the Cabinet Office on September 14. In the National Strategy Conference held on September 18, civilian members expressed opposition, and the approval of the strategy didn't happen.


There is no hidden agenda behind the way they decided. Now that's unintentionally funny.

Jiji Tsushin is kind enough to make excuse for the minister by citing the precedent, as if that would make it OK to omit the "zero nuke" reference from the formal cabinet decision, after the unprecedented 90,000 public comments on the nuclear energy policy flooded the office of Mr. Furukawa.

The omission is called "plausible deniability". Twenty years from now when all these politicians have long gone to the politicians' heaven or into the cushy retirement, no one will care to know how the decision was made, except by looking at what was written down on paper. Since no mention of "zero nuclear plants in 2030 or 2030s" is found in the document, there will be no reason for the administration at that time (if Japan lasts that long as a nation, given the Chinese threat of dumping Japanese bonds) to make that happen.

German Chancellor Welcomes Japan's Zero Nuke Policy, But Noda Admin Drops It After Protest from Big Business Lobby and Doubt from IAEA


Oops. Ms. Merkel should have waited one more day.

On September 18, as Jiji Press (English) reported the Chancellor's comments on September 17:

Vienna, Sept. 17 (Jiji Press)--German Chancellor Angela Merkel welcomed on Monday a new strategy of the Japanese government to lower dependence on nuclear power to zero in the 2030s.

Merkel said at a news conference in Berlin that she expresses respect for Japan's decision and that she hopes the two nations will strengthen cooperation in converting to renewable energy sources.

Since the nuclear accident in March 2011 at Tokyo Electric Power Co.'s <9501> Fukushima No. 1 power plant, Germany has worked closely with Japan on energy policy, Merkel said.

She said Germany is pleased to continue cooperation with Japan and that Japan must be looking for stronger cooperation.

The chancellor said Germany hopes to share information with Japan on energy efficiency, the introduction of renewable energy and the expansion of power grids.


But one day later on September 19, the same Jiji Tsushin (Japanese) first reported:

原発ゼロ、「閣議文書に入らず」=枝野経産相

Zero Nuke is "Not in the Cabinet document", says Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry Edano

 枝野幸男経済産業相は19日の閣議後記者会見で、2030年代の原発稼働ゼロを目指す「革新的エネルギー・環境戦略」について、「閣議決定の文書には入っていないが、閣議でオーソライズされた」と述べた。

In the press conference after the cabinet meeting on September 19, Yukio Edano, Minister of Economy, Trade and Industry said that the new energy and environmental strategy that aims at zero nuclear power plant operating in 2030s "is not mentioned in the document for the cabinet decision, but it was authorized in the cabinet meeting."


If you scratch your head and wonder aloud what the hell Mr. Edano meant, here's the minister in charge of national strategy, no less:

新エネ戦略、閣議決定見送り=政府

The administration put off the cabinet decision on the new energy strategy

古川元久国家戦略担当相は19日、新エネルギー戦略の閣議決定を見送ったことを明らかにした。

Yoshihisa Furukawa, minister in charge of national strategy, said that the cabinet decision on the new energy strategy had been put off.


So, with the Keidanren's chairman threatening to resign from the national strategy council over the zero nuke policy and IAEA expressing doubts about the implication of zero nuke on the production of plutonium, the Noda administration simply drops the zero nuke strategy which they embraced reluctantly anyway to win popularity in the coming Lower House election.

And guess what. Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda is expected to win the Democratic Party of Japan's leadership election in a landslide.